South Shore

The South Shore of Staten Island is a geographical region situated in the borough of Staten Island, New York City.

Geographically, it is generally defined as the area south and east of the island’s ridge of hills, stretching along the waterfront from the Narrows to the mouth of the Arthur Kill. A more specific definition includes neighborhoods between the Raritan Bay shoreline and Richmond Creek and Fresh Kills, from Great Kills to Tottenville. The neighboring East Shore comprises communities along Lower New York Bay.

History

The South Shore was a glacial outwash plain that evolved into a prominent area for oyster harvesting. It remained largely undeveloped until the construction of the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge in 1964, which spurred rapid urbanization and population growth. Residential development expanded southward, replacing summer bungalows with larger homes and developing areas near creeks such as Lemon Creek. Today, the area features a combination of shopping centers and small businesses. The South Shore also hosts several historical landmarks dating back to the 1600s, including Sandy Ground, a 19th-century community established by free Black New Yorkers, and the Conference House in Tottenville, a site of a Revolutionary War meeting. Other notable landmarks include the Kreischer Mansion in Charleston and Conference House Park.

Notable Attractions

Natural areas and parks in the region include Great Kills Park, Wolfe’s Pond Park in Prince’s Bay, Seaside Wildlife Nature Park, Mount Loretto Unique Area, Cedar Grove Beach, and the Franklin D. Roosevelt Boardwalk and Beach.

Neighborhoods

Communities within the South Shore encompass Annadale, Arden Heights, Charleston, Eltingville, Great Kills, Huguenot, Pleasant Plains, Prince’s Bay, Richmond Valley, Rossville, Tottenville, and Woodrow.

Weather Forecast

STATEN ISLAND WEATHER FORECAST

Homes for sale on the South Shore

Sold for $1,9 million on Staten Island’s South Shore: a 4-bedroom and 5-bathroom home in the Annadale neighborhood, offering 6,800 square feet of living space within a generous 14,000-square-foot lot.

Staten Island’s southern neighborhoods offer a relaxed pace and a warm community vibe, setting them apart from the busier parts of New York City. Here, you’ll enjoy charming tree-lined streets, easy access to the waterfront, and a close-knit atmosphere that continues to attract those looking for space and stability. If you’re exploring homes for sale on the South Shore, you’ll find this area stands out for its cozy residential feel and convenient, everyday living.

What is considered the South Shore of Staten Island?

The South Shore includes the southern stretch of Staten Island, from Great Kills to Tottenville, along the waterfront. Known for its suburban charm, this area features single-family homes and established, welcoming neighborhoods.
Many buyers appreciate the South Shore for its spacious, suburban vibe, offering quiet streets, plenty of green space, and a layout that feels more like a traditional neighborhood, all without leaving New York City.

How close is the South Shore to Manhattan, Brooklyn, and New Jersey?

The South Shore is closest to New Jersey (10-30 minutes), moderately close to Brooklyn (25-45 minutes)), and farthest from Manhattan (45-90 minutes) in terms of commute time.

• You can reach Manhattan via the Staten Island Railway and the Staten Island Ferry, which offer free rides to Lower Manhattan.
• The Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge makes it easier to get to Brooklyn.
• There are direct routes to New Jersey via the Outerbridge Crossing and Goethals Bridge.

On Staten Island, residents enjoy the convenience of being close to New York City and New Jersey while coming home to a quiet, friendly community.

HOMES FOR SALE ON THE SOUTH SHORE OF STATEN ISLAND, NY

A 15,000-square foot luxury oceanfront estate on the South Shore of Staten Island estate features unobstructed ocean views, 10- to 30-foot ceilings, and features 7 bedrooms and 11 bathrooms designed for multigenerational living.

A 15,000-square foot luxury oceanfront estate on the South Shore of Staten Island estate features unobstructed ocean views, 10- to 30-foot ceilings, and features 7 bedrooms and 11 bathrooms designed for multigenerational living.

What kinds of homes can you find here?

The South Shore is best known for its single-family homes, but it also has townhouses, semi-attached properties, and new developments in some neighborhoods.

Popular features include:

• Private driveways and garages
• Backyards and outdoor living spaces
• Larger interior layouts compared to other NYC boroughs

Many of these homes have long-term owners, which means well-maintained properties and inviting, cohesive streetscapes. If you’re looking at real estate on Staten Island, NY the South Shore offers classic suburban-style residences, as well as luxury estates.

Are South Shore homes affordable compared to other parts of Staten Island?

While costs shift depending on the neighborhood and home style, the South Shore generally offers greater value than, typically staying well within the mid-six-figure range.

View the latest South Shore prices here.

Compared to Brooklyn or Manhattan, you can find larger houses with more land at a more accessible price.

Within Staten Island:

• The South Shore may be priced higher than some North Shore areas due to high demand for suburban living.
• It competes with Mid-Island neighborhoods, especially for move-in-ready properties.

Homes for sale on the South Shore of Staten Island offer a balance between cost and lifestyle for those looking for long-term living spaces.

What are some of the top neighborhoods on the South Shore?

Each has its own unique charm, but all share a friendly, residential atmosphere.

• Tottenville – At the southern tip, known for historic homes, waterfront views, and a laid-back vibe. You’ll find a mix of old, charming properties and new builds in a peaceful setting.
• Great Kills – Outdoor recreation and transit are nearby, including parks, marinas, and the Staten Island Railway.
• Eltingville – This centrally located neighborhood is convenient for shopping and public transportation.
• Annadale and Huguenot – Known for quiet streets and large lots, these neighborhoods provide privacy and a sense of community while staying close to amenities.
• Pleasant Plains and Charleston – With new developments, more space, and proximity to outdoor spots like the Staten Island Greenbelt, these South Shore neighborhoods are ideal for those seeking a modern home in a peaceful environment.

Contact us to learn about homes for sale in these neighborhoods.

LIVING ON THE SOUTH SHORE OF STATEN ISLAND, NY

Families feel at home in South Shore neighborhoods, featuring quiet streets, parks, and top-rated schools.

What amenities and attractions are near South Shore homes?

South Shore holds the highest concentration of preserved land, offering more green space per capita than almost any other NYC region.

Residents won’t have to leave the borough for a true escape. Outdoor enthusiasts can hit the coastal trails of Great Kills Park right here on the South Shore or take a short trip to explore the massive Staten Island Greenbelt trail system.

While the parks are the crown jewels, the South Shore’s truly suburban lifestyle is supported by a mix of high-end convenience, deep-rooted community institutions, and some of the most reliable transit hubs on the island.

Is the South Shore a wonderful area for families?

Absolutely! The South Shore is one of Staten Island’s most family-oriented areas. Families are drawn to properties with more space and yards, streets that feel less crowded, and friendly neighbors.

Families who move to the South Shore also benefit from its:

• Top-tier education, thanks to School District 31, which consistently ranks among the highest-performing in New York City.
• Unmatched safety and security, with the neighborhood of Annadale noted for a 92% safer rating than other NYC neighborhoods with a property crime rate of only 11 per 1,000 residents.
• Peak community spirit, with neighborhoods like Eltingville, Great Kills, and Annadale featuring numerous youth sports leagues, community libraries, and annual family festivals.

These qualities make the South Shore a practical and appealing choice for families looking for a long-term place to settle.

Explore family-friendly neighborhoods on the South Shore with us today

What makes the South Shore especially attractive for long-term residents?

South Shore attracts long-term residents because the community isn’t just a place to live; it’s a place to stay for generations.

• Unlike the transient nature of many NYC neighborhoods, the South Shore is dominated by owner-occupied, single-family homes.
• It is common to find families who have lived in neighborhoods like Eltingville or Great Kills, for decades, with children often buying homes near their parents.
• Property values on the South Shore tend to remain stable, making a home here a reliable long-term asset.

How does the South Shore compare to the North Shore and Mid-Island?

Compared to the North Shore and Mid-Island, the South Shore is the most suburban, residential, and affluent region of Staten Island.

While the North Shore is defined by its urban density and the Mid-Island by its commercial convenience, the South Shore prioritizes a small-town atmosphere with larger properties and the borough’s lowest crime rates.

FIND YOUR DREAM HOME ON STATEN ISLAND’S SOUTH SHORE

Starting your home search is easier when you work with a team that truly understands the local market. Homes R Us Realty has proudly served Staten Island since 2000 and has consistently ranked among the top 10 real estate companies in the borough for over 15 years.

With a dedicated team of 58 agents focused on residential sales, we offer extensive experience working with buyers, sellers, investors, and builders.

If you’re ready to explore homes for sale on the South Shore of Staten Island, our seasoned team of real estate agents is here to help you find your ideal property and guide you on your home-buying journey.

Take the first step toward your South Shore home today. Call us at 718.668.2550 or send us an email.